3. Compositional Aspects

7 Mins to read

Share
Dark
Light

3. Compositional Aspects

7 Mins to read

Share
Dark
Light

Article summary

Did you find this summary helpful?

Thank you for your feedback

General Foods
Australia

This section provides the compositional requirements for the food category and/or food products in scope and information on permitted nutrients, ingredients, and additives.

3.1 Composition Requirements

The FSC includes compositional requirements for all foods in the Chapter 1 standards [1], including those relating to:

Ingredients
Use of processing aids and food additives
Permitted flavors and colors
Materials produced using genetic modification techniques
Novel foods
Irradiation of foods or ingredients

Under Standard 1.1.1 [2], there are compositional requirements for foods for sale, including:

Permission to use another food as an ingredient in a food

Figure 1: Compositional requirements from sections 1.1.1-10 (2) and (3) of ref [2].

This means that a food (including whisky) can contain any other food as an ingredient, providing that the added food ingredient is permitted for use in that particular food type and all other relevant compositional requirements are met. This permits the blending of whiskies from different sources.

In the specific standard that applies to whisky, Standard 2.7.5 [3], the addition of other foods as ingredients would be more restricted than in General Foods due to the definition of a spirit, particularly given that the ‘taste, aroma and other characteristics generally attributed’ would apply.

Figure 2: Definition of ‘spirit’.

While this does not mean other ingredients could not be added, any additions would need to maintain the organoleptic features expected of a whisky. This would not restrict the permissions for other components such as food additives, colors, flavors, etc., unless they altered the expected organoleptic profile. The requirements for these are described in Sections 3.5 (permitted additives), 3.6 (permitted flavors and colors), and 3.7 (permitted processing aids). Compositional information relating to the use of materials produced using genetic modification techniques, Novel foods, and irradiated ingredients is provided in Section 3.8.

3.2 Raw Material Requirements

The FSC does not mandate particular specifications for most individual ingredients. Standard 1.1.1 [2] includes information for relevant specifications with regard to purity and identity for substances used as food additives, processing aids, nutritive substances, and Novel foods.

Figure 3: Identity and purity provisions from clause 1.1.1-15 of ref [2].

Schedule 3 [3] provides information on specifications on identity and purity from primary sources (Figure 4) and secondary sources (Figure 5). Schedule 3 also contains information for named substances. Since the list of named substances is lengthy, it will not be reproduced here. It is available in the table to clause S3-2 [3].

Figure 4. Primary sources from clause S3-2 of ref [3].

Figure 5. Secondary sources from clause S3-3 of ref [3].

3.3 Fortification

While the FSC permits fortification with vitamins, minerals and nutritional substances for some foods and beverages, this does not extend to alcoholic beverages.

3.4 Other Permitted Ingredients

N/A

3.5 Permitted Additives

Standard 1.3.1 [4] outlines the requirements for food additives. Unless expressly permitted by the FSC, a food additive cannot be used (refer to Figure 6). A substance used as a food additive is required to:

(1) to be permitted as such a substance (Figure 7) and

(2) perform a technological function (Figure 8) as described in Schedule 14 [5]

Figure 6: Permission for food additives from clause 1.1.1-10 (6) of ref [2].

Figure 7. Definition of food additive from clause 1.3.1-2 of ref [4].

Figure 8: Technological functions for food additives from ref [5].

Lists of permitted food additives are provided in Schedule 15 [6], which describes permissions by food category, and Schedule 16 [7], which provides lists of additives that can be used at GMP.

3.6 Permitted Flavors and Colors

Flavors and colors are considered to be food additives. Therefore, the general comments in Section 3.5 above regarding food additives apply. Additional information is provided below.

Colorings

Permitted colorings at GMP are listed in Clause S16-3 [7]:

Figure 9. Colorings permitted at GMP from clause S16-3 of ref [7]. The numbers are corresponding food additive numbers.

In addition, some colorings are permitted when used up to a maximum level:

Figure 10. Colorings permitted with limits from clause S16-4 of ref [7]. The numbers are corresponding food additive numbers. Limits for use are as per Figure 11.

Clause 1.3.1-4 (3) [4] provided the maximum limits:

Figure 11. Levels for colorings permitted at a maximum level from clause 1.3.1-4 (3) of ref [4].

Where more than one coloring agent is used, the limit in Figure 11 is for total colors. Colorings may contain other food additives as permitted in Schedule 15 [6]:

Figure 12: Permission for foods additives for coloring substance from ref [6].

Flavorings

Permitted flavoring substances are described in Standard 1.1.2 [8].

Figure 13. Permission for flavoring substances from clause 1.1.2 -2 (3) of ref [8].

In addition, flavorings may contain other food additives as permitted in Schedule 15 [6] (Figure 14).

Figure 14. Permission for foods additives for flavoring substance from ref [6]. Limits are in mg/kg or at GMP.

3.7 Permitted Processing Aids

The FSC permits the use of processing aids under Standard 1.3.3 [9] per Figure 15.

Figure 15. Permission for processing aids from clause 1.3.3 – 3 of ref [9].

Some processing aids are permitted for all foods (Figure 16). These are those substances that are

(1) additives permitted at GMP (substances in Schedule 16 [7]), or

(2) substances listed in the table to Schedule 18-2 [10] (figure 17).

Figure 16. Generally permitted processing aids from clause 1.3.3 – 4 of ref [9].

Figure 17: Permission for processing aids for certain purposes from clause 1.3.3 – 5 of ref [9].

Further sections in Schedule 18 [10] detail permissions for processing aids in particular foods or purposes. The lists are by technological function and, as they are lengthy, they will not be provided here. In relation to production of ‘potable alcohol’, there are many permitted enzymes of genetically modified origin.

3.8 Additional Notes

In addition to the compositional requirements described in the sections above, the FSC has requirements [2] relating to Novel food ingredients, use of components of genetically modified origin, and irradiation of foods or food ingredients.

Figure 18. Use of Novel foods, GMO, and irradiation from clause 1.1.1 – 10 (6) of ref [2].

Novel foods

While it is not expected that the whisky products would contain Novel foods, the following information is provided for reference purposes should this change due to product development requirements. FSANZ defines foods and food ingredients as 'traditional' or 'non-traditional'. Novel foods are a subcategory of non-traditional foods, and require prior approval before use in foods.

Figure 19. Definitions for non-traditional food and Novel food from clause 1.1.2-8 of ref [8].

Novel foods require an assessment due to possible safety issues. These are only allowed to be used in foods once approved and entered into the Schedule 25 [11] per Standard 1.5.1 [12].

Genetically modified (GMO) ingredients

Standard 1.5.2 [13] describes the requirements for the use of ingredients that have been produced using gene technology.

Figure 20: When GMO food/ingredients can be used from Clause 1.5.2-3 of ref [13].

The positive list of GMO permissions in Schedule 26 [14] is long and will not be provided here. To be clear, any ingredient permitted to be used as a processing aid or food additive is permitted even if it is derived from a GMO source. While food containing GMO components needs to be labeled as such, there are exemptions under Clause 1.5.2-4 [13]:

Figure 21. Labeling of food with GMO from Clause 1.5.2-4 of ref [13].

It is expected that the use of any GMO crop used as a substrate for whisky distillation would not result in any novel DNA or novel protein being in the final product, and therefore GMO labeling would not be required. This would need to be checked on a case-by-case basis for whisky products.

Irradiated foods

Standard 1.5.3 [15] describes the requirements for the use of irradiation. It is not expected that the bakery products would be irradiated or contain irradiated ingredients. However, if a food product has been irradiated or contains irradiated ingredients, there is a requirement for the product labeling of B2C products (both retail and catering).